0

Mattress Reviews

Mattress Reviews from The Sleep Sherpa find the Best Mattress for You!

mattress reviews

This post contains affiliate links, which means I receive a commission if you make a purchase using these links. For full details visit the disclosures page

Since starting this site, I have been able to conduct dozens of mattress reviews from online mattress start-ups to big name retail brands. Below are mattresses that I have personally tested. This can be an overwhelming list. There are a few brands that really stand out including Nest, Winkbed and Brentwood Home. I have many Brentwood Home models listed here. Click the banner below for an overview of this awesome brand.

Brentwood Home Review

Also

If you have any questions about these mattress reviews, please email me at [email protected] I’m happy to help!

Memory Foam Mattresses

This is the largest category of mattresses. Many of the new startups created a mattress in a box made of layers of glued foam with the advent of roll packing machines that could compress the foam into boxes that can be shipped via UPS, FedEx or a similar carrier.

NAMERATINGStatisticsLINK
1

Alexander Signature Select

94.4
Read review
Motion Transfer
97
Affordability
90
Softness
95
Off Gassing
95
Alexander Signature
2

Sierra

93.4
Read review
Motion Transfer
92
Affordability
93
Softness
94
Off Gassing
93
Sierra
3

Novosbed

91.4
Read review
Motion Transfer
97
Affordability
85
Softness
92
Off Gassing
90
Novosbed
4

Lull

90.6
Read review
Motion Transfer
96
Affordability
91
Softness
88
Off Gassing
88
Lull
5

Leesa

90
Read review
Motion Transfer
89
Affordability
89
Softness
97
Off Gassing
85
Leesa
6

Cocoon

89
Read review
Motion Transfer
95
Affordability
89
Softness
90
Off Gassing
80
Cocoon
7

Brooklyn Bedding

88.8
Read review
Motion Transfer
85
Affordability
89
Softness
89
Off Gassing
91
Brooklyn Bedding
8

4Sleep

88.8
Read review
Motion Transfer
90
Affordability
92
Softness
88
Off Gassing
85
4Sleep
9

Doze

88.6
Read review
Motion Transfer
87
Affordability
92
Softness
93
Off Gassing
83
Doze
10

GhostBed

88.6
Read review
Motion Transfer
88
Affordability
93
Softness
83
Off Gassing
89
GhostBed
11

Ikrema Mattress

88.4
Read review
Motion Transfer
89
Affordability
93
Softness
90
Off Gassing
80
Ikrema
12

Loom & Leaf

88.2
Read review
Motion Transfer
90
Affordability
81
Softness
88
Off Gassing
92
Loom & Leaf
13

Hyphen

87.6
Read review
Motion Transfer
88
Affordability
87
Softness
88
Off Gassing
85
Hyphen
14

HIBR

86.4
Read review
Motion Transfer
87
Affordability
85
Softness
85
Off Gassing
85
HIBR
15

Nolah Mattress

86.4
Read review
Motion Transfer
90
Affordability
82
Softness
85
Off Gassing
85
Nolah
16

Zotto

86
Read review
Motion Transfer
88
Affordability
85
Softness
85
Off Gassing
82
Zotto
17

Dromma

85.8
Read review
Motion Transfer
87
Affordability
88
Softness
93
Off Gassing
75
Dromma
18

Live and Sleep

85.25
Read review
Motion Transfer
89
Affordability
90
Softness
84
Off Gassing
78
Live and Sleep
19

Endy

85
Read review
Motion Transfer
87
Affordability
93
Softness
95
Off Gassing
65
ENDY
20

Eve Mattress

83.8
Read review
Motion Transfer
87
Affordability
93
Softness
84
Off Gassing
70
Eve
21

S-Bed

82.4
Read review
Motion Transfer
80
Affordability
97
Softness
70
Off Gassing
80
S-Bed
22

YogaBed

81
Read review
Motion Transfer
87
Affordability
87
Softness
90
Off Gassing
60
YogaBed
23

Tuft & Needle

77
Read review
Motion Transfer
91
Affordability
97
Softness
60
Off Gassing
60
Tuft & Needle
24

Nature's Sleep Emerald Gel

76.75
Read review
Motion Transfer
97
Affordability
70
Softness
85
Off Gassing
55
Nature's Sleep
25

Danican

71
Read review
Motion Transfer
90
Affordability
40
Softness
95
Off Gassing
30
Danican

Inner Spring Mattresses

These mattresses have inner springs in typically in the form of pocket coils. Some are delivered by a freight carrier since they are not roll packed but you can purchase them online. A growing trend is hybrid mattresses that include both memory foam and coils so that you get contouring and a little bit of bounce too.

NAMERATINGStatisticsLINK
1

WinkBeds

90.4
Read review
Motion Transfer
91
Affordability
85
Softness
92
Off Gassing
97
WinkBeds
2

Alexander Hybrid

89.6
Read review
Motion Transfer
88
Affordability
85
Softness
90
Off Gassing
95
Alexander Hybrid
3

Aviya

85.75
Read review
Motion Transfer
81
Affordability
87
Softness
85
Off Gassing
90
Aviya
4

Saatva Luxury Firm

84.8
Read review
Motion Transfer
81
Affordability
87
Softness
82
Off Gassing
91
Saatva

Performance Mattresses

Performance mattresses are the next generation of mattresses. They can often be customized to particular sleep preferences or offer a new technology beyond just memory foam. This category includes some really innovative products.

NAMERATINGStatisticsLINK
1

Luxi

94.5
Read review
Motion Transfer
93
Affordability
90
Trial Period
100
Luxi
2

Eight Sleep

91.4
Read review
Motion Transfer
90
Affordability
90
Trial Period
92
Eight Sleep
3

Layla

91.25
Read review
Motion Transfer
89
Affordability
93
Trial Period
95
Layla
4

Helix Sleep

90.8333333333
Read review
Motion Transfer
90
Affordability
87
Trial Period
90
Helix
5

Active X

90.6
Read review
Motion Transfer
96
Affordability
90
Trial Period
95
Active X
6

Purple

90.3333333333
Read review
Motion Transfer
92
Affordability
83
Trial Period
95
Purple
7

Pangea Bed

90
Read review
Motion Transfer
90
Affordability
90
Trial Period
90
Pangea Bed
8

Bear Mattress

89.1666666667
Read review
Motion Transfer
90
Affordability
90
Trial Period
90
Bear Mattress
9

Amerisleep Revere

88.8
Read review
Motion Transfer
92
Affordability
86
Trial Period
90
Amerisleep
10

BioPosture

87.4
Read review
Motion Transfer
92
Affordability
85
Trial Period
90
BioPosture

Luxury Mattresses

The Luxury category includes mattresses at a higher price point. They may be more labor intensive to make such as hand tufting or incorporate more expensive materials.

NAMERATINGStatisticsLINK
1

Brentwood Home Oceano

93.2
Read review
Motion Transfer
95
Affordability
90
Softness
93
Off Gassing
96
Trial Period
92
Oceano
2

Wright

92
Read review
Motion Transfer
95
Affordability
90
Softness
93
Off Gassing
90
Trial Period
92
Wright
3

Sequioa

91.6
Read review
Motion Transfer
92
Affordability
94
Softness
84
Off Gassing
96
Trial Period
92
Sequioa
4

Sapira

91.4
Read review
Motion Transfer
90
Affordability
90
Softness
90
Off Gassing
95
Trial Period
92
Sapira
5

SmartHouse Cool Sleeper

91.2
Read review
Motion Transfer
85
Affordability
92
Softness
89
Off Gassing
95
Trial Period
95
SmartHouse Cool Sleeper

Luxury Performance Mattresses

The Luxury Performance mattress category is for mattresses that are at a higher price point and also offer proprietary technology.

NAMERATINGStatisticsLINK
1

Reverie Dream Supreme

90
Read review
Motion Transfer
95
Affordability
70
Off Gassing
90
Trial Period
95
Reverie
2

Intellibed

Read review
Motion Transfer
Affordability
Off Gassing
Trial Period
Intellibed

All Natural Mattresses

Not to be confused with organic, All Natural mattresses are those that use primarily natural materials such as natural latex, cotton covers, etc.

NAMERATINGStatisticsLINK
1

Avocado Mattress

90.6
Read review
Motion Transfer
80
Affordability
93
Softness
85
Off Gassing
100
Trial Period
95
Avocado
2

My Green Mattress

90.4
Read review
Motion Transfer
87
Affordability
90
Softness
85
Off Gassing
100
Trial Period
90
Natural Escape
3

Zen Haven

90
Read review
Motion Transfer
85
Affordability
90
Softness
95
Off Gassing
95
Trial Period
85
Zen Haven
4

Nest Hybrid Latex

89
Read review
Motion Transfer
85
Affordability
85
Softness
90
Off Gassing
95
Trial Period
90
Hybrid Latex
5

Abscond Spindle Mattress

78
Read review
Motion Transfer
85
Affordability
90
Softness
75
Off Gassing
100
Trial Period
40
Spindle
6

Savvy Rest

71.8
Read review
Motion Transfer
80
Affordability
55
Softness
84
Off Gassing
100
Trial Period
40
Savvy Rest

Store Brands

These mattresses can be found online and in stores such as Mattress Firm.

NAMERATINGStatisticsLINK
1

Simmons BeautyRest Recharge

66
Read review
Motion Transfer
80
Affordability
70
Softness
50
Off Gassing
90
Trial Period
40
Recharge
2

Tempurpedic Cloud Supreme Breeze

64.5
Read review
Motion Transfer
95
Affordability
20
Softness
80
Off Gassing
75
Trial Period
30
Tempurpedic

Mattresses Under $600

If you are looking for a mattress and are on a budget, consider these brands below. These mattresses retail for under $600 for a queen. The quality of these mattresses is good but they may not have all the features as some of the higher priced models.

NAMERATINGStatisticsLINK
1

Love and Sleep Mattress

92.2
Read review
Motion Transfer
91
Affordability
90
Softness
95
Off Gassing
95
Trial Period
90
Love and Sleep
2

eLuxury Supply

91.2
Read review
Motion Transfer
91
Affordability
92
Softness
91
Off Gassing
89
Trial Period
93
eLuxury Supply
3

Zinus Green Tea

90.6
Read review
Motion Transfer
95
Affordability
97
Softness
98
Off Gassing
88
Trial Period
75
Green Tea
4

Aveline

90.2
Read review
Motion Transfer
88
Affordability
96
Softness
90
Off Gassing
84
Trial Period
93
Aveline
5

Bamboo Gel 13

90
Read review
Motion Transfer
96
Affordability
98
Softness
85
Off Gassing
78
Trial Period
93
Bamboo Gel 13
6

Elysse Mattress

86.6
Read review
Motion Transfer
90
Affordability
95
Softness
85
Off Gassing
88
Trial Period
75
Elysse
7

Zinus Pocket Spring

86.4
Read review
Motion Transfer
85
Affordability
98
Softness
85
Off Gassing
89
Trial Period
75
Pocketed Spring
8

Sunrisingbed

77.2
Read review
Motion Transfer
90
Affordability
90
Softness
81
Off Gassing
65
Trial Period
60
Sunrisingbed

I have owned many mattresses during my lifetime and although each person is different when it comes to sleep preferences, I can say that quality matters. But more expensive doesn’t always mean quality. You can see from my reviews above that some of the best rated mattresses aren’t all that expensive. You just need to know which companies are reputable and stand by their product.

Mattress and bedding technology is developing rapidly and these mattresses are at the forefront of that development. If you haven’t upgraded your mattress in the past 5 years, you are in for a treat!